The heavy toll of coal mining in South Africa

Published by MAC on 2015-04-06
Source: Al Jazeera, Bloomberg

The heavy toll of coal mining in South Africa

South Africa's coal-powered energy sector brings environmental devastation despite legal regulations

Victoria Schneider

Al Jazeera

2 April 2015

Emalahleni, South Africa - Everything in Andries Evans' house is coated in black dust. It has invaded his sofas, the Jesus picture on the wall, the plastic cups and plates in his kitchen, and the old man himself.

He is a skinny, fragile man who looks much older than his 59 years. His red cap is dirty, his shirt and jogging pants are dirty. Everything is blackened from the coal his crumbling brick house is built upon.

The old man looked up and stuck his finger through the tin roof, as if it were going through soft butter.

"Look, it is all old and eroded."

He said he feels the dust is not good for him, he is short of breath and feels weak. Even after 35 years, he cannot get used to the life on the Highveld of South Africa, an area that is said to have some of the highest air pollution levels in the world.

MNS is one of many informal settlements around the city of Emalahleni, "the place of coal" in Zulu, in the province of Mpumalanga, where decades of excessive coal mining has taken its toll on the environment.

The area of Emalahleni was declared a "High Priority Area" by the South African government in 2007 due to the hazardous substances in the air.

Among the issues scientists have found are elevated carbon dioxide emissions, sulphur dioxide in the air, heavy metals in the soil and acidic groundwater. These were linked to the 22 collieries in Mpumalanga, as well as the 12 coal-fired power stations - of the country's 16.

A new power station, Kusile, is planned to be completed in 2017 and will make pollution levels even worse, environmental experts warn.

"Now that we are going through a power crisis the government relies even more on coal," said Tracey Davies, an attorney from the Centre for Environmental Rights in Cape Town.

"It is the easiest and quickest way to generate power, so we are just following this path without considering the consequences."

Grim consequences

Generating more power through coal means more coal must be extracted.

But South Africa, which currently generates 90 percent of its electricity through coal, is already struggling with the devastating impacts of more than a century of excessive mining.

A stroll around Emalahleni is enough to get a feel for the impact coal has had the environment.

The landscape shines in bright colours, layers of white and yellow cover former riverbeds and grasslands that were transformed into mining areas.

There are no leaves on the trees, and the waters are clear and lifeless. Thick fog looms in the air.

"Acid mine drainage," said Matthews Hlabane from the Southern African Green Revolutionary Council who has been monitoring the area for almost 30 years.

"The pH levels around here are below 1. Some residents of the informal settlements say that birds fall dead from the sky when they fly over the area."

Hlabane laughs sarcastically. "In a few decades we are going to fight wars over water."

He took Al Jazeera to areas in which coal seems have been burning underground for decades, where sinkholes and polluted groundwater from abandoned mines are a hazard to the surrounding communities.

Children play on the old mine dumps and adults collect the coal waste for domestic fires.

"If nothing happens we are going to lose all our water resources," said Hlabane.

"The Olifants river is already contaminated and we are on our way to do the same to the Limpopo river."

Worldwide demand

South Africa is not the only country to have chosen coal as the way forward in the near future.

Demand for coal is growing worldwide. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), it has been "the fastest-growing global energy source of the 21st century", ensuring 40 percent of the world's electricity supply in 2014.

The IEA predicts that China will account for three-fifths of global demand growth in the next 5 years, followed by India and other Asian nations.

At the launch of the IEA's annual Coal Market report last December, executive director Maria van der Hoeven said "coal use in its current form is simply unsustainable".

Energy production through coal releases sulphur dioxide, nitrogen dioxides and particulate matter (PM) at levels that exceed the maximum recommended by the World Health Organization, she said.

Even Europe, whose countries are investing more and more in renewable energies, still derives a third of its power from the most carbon-intensive fossil fuel.

These trends ignore the numerous studies that have proved the negative impacts of coal mining on the environment, for which South Africa serves as a prime example.

Acid mine drainage

"Acid mine drainage from coal mining areas has had a devastating impact on water resources, with acidification of rivers and streams, elevated metal levels and consequent fish die-offs", said a report released by the WWF South Africa in 2011.

Another study conducted by Greenpeace concluded that "decades of coal [mining] have poisoned the landscape and driven the Olifants River to a crisis point".

The study suggested that the pollution levels are the cause of more than 2,000 premature deaths per year in South Africa.

Attorney Tracey Davies holds the government responsible for this "nightmare disaster". She said the lawmakers are failing to monitor and enforce the "wonderful policies" South Africa has regarding the rehabilitation of the environment.

"The Department of Mineral Resources is granting more and more licences without making sure that the shafts are adequately closed."

The law urges the companies to rehabilitate an area concurrently, while they are mining it.

"But it is simply not happening," she said.

Phuti Mabelebele from the Department of Petroleum and Minerals, which regulates the duties of mining companies to prevent environmental damage, says that currently 263 mining licences have been granted, and more than 500 prospecting rights.

"Mining companies are expected to comply with the mine environmental policy," she told Al Jazeera. She explained that "there is a mine rehabilitation programme in place that companies comply with," although she did not elaborate on the nature of the programme.

The Bench Marks Foundation of South Africa insists that action must be taken. The NGO released a report last year, saying that there are at least 6,000 abandoned mines in Mpumalanga - 160 of these are around Emalahleni - which are spilling acid water and heavy metals into the environment.

"We call for obligatory transparency by mining corporations regarding mine closure plans," said John Capel, the CEO of the NGO.

"Thousands of communities are living in areas that should have been closed off due to extremely hazardous conditions".

Sitting on fire

He refers to places like Coronation, an informal settlement on the other side of Emalahleni. It looks like a post-apocalyptic film set - hills over hills of blackness, interrupted by sinkholes that cut through the landscape like giant scars.

The settlement is named after the mining operation it was built on, which was owned by Anglo American Coal and closed in the late 1940s.

"I know this is not safe," said Salome Elem, a local resident, as she stood on the ridge of the dump, shovelling coal into a large bucket.

She said she doesn't want her four-year-old son to play in the area because of the sinkholes and the dust that she thinks are dangerous. Two boys were recently burned to death after falling into an abandoned mine shaft, she recalled.

She looked fearfully at Matthews Hlabane as the activist explained that the ground underneath her shack could collapse at any moment.

"I know where we are standing is not safe ... but my house?" she asked.

Every day she collects coal for domestic use. She is one of millions of households in South Africa who don't have access to power, although the wires supplying the mines are visible from where she digs.

"You say there is a power problem in South Africa?" she laughed.

"I cook with coal and use solar power for light."

Elem pointed towards a red and white shack, less than 50m away. On the roof is a solar panel. It generates just enough power to light a weak bulb and charge their phones at night.

"Most of the people in Coronation have started using solar," Elem said.

---

Sasol coal miners seek damages over lung disease

by Agency staff

Bloomberg

3 April 2015

COAL miners in South Africa who worked at a unit of Sasol and contracted lung diseases filed a suit seeking damages from the company, according to their lawyer.

The 22 current and former workers contracted illnesses "as a result of their employment" at the fuel manufacturer’s South African mines where they were exposed to coal dust, Richard Spoor, a Johannesburg-based attorney, said in an e-mailed statement. He submitted the civil action at the South Gauteng High Court on Thursday.

Sasol is "currently assessing the law suit," spokesman Alex Anderson said in an e-mailed reply to questions on Friday. "While we cannot provide further comment as the legal process is under way, Sasol Mining takes the protection of the health and safety of our employees and the employees of service providers very seriously."

The miners worked at sites near Secunda in Mpumalanga province, about 140 kilometres east of Johannesburg, for different durations between 1971 and now, Mr Spoor said in the statement. Coal dust can cause lung diseases including coal workers’ pneumoconiosis, progressive massive fibrosis and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, he said.

The miners "allege that Sasol Mining failed to provide and maintain a working environment in its mines that was safe and without risk to the health of its employees and that it failed to comply with the statutory and common law duties," according to the statement. Personal protective equipment wasn’t provided and employees weren’t made aware of the danger of coal dust, according to the statement.

"Sasol Mining continuously adheres to the Mine Health and Safety Act, as well as all other applicable legislation," Anderson said. "We remain committed to promoting a healthy workforce through a proactive and strategic approach to occupational health."

Mr Spoor won a R490m settlement from Gencor in 2003 after representing South African workers at the company’s asbestos mines. The country’s highest court in March 2011 cleared the way for him to seek damages from gold companies by ruling that former miner Thembekile Mankayi could pursue a R2.7m claim against AngloGold Ashanti, a company whose predecessor was formed in 1997 when Anglo American merged its gold mines.

The Mankayi ruling has also made the Sasol litigation possible, Mr Spoor said. More coal-mining claims may be made, he said.